I have love/hate thoughts about this picture. I love it because it is a picture of my youngest daughter, Maxine, and me during her school trip to Washington DC last year. I remember the moment the shutter was snapped, and we both have great smiles on our faces.
I hate the picture because my hair is flat and wind-blown; there are bags under my eyes, and I’m not wearing a spot of makeup. And in these days where most people sport blinding white teeth, my toothy smile reveals teeth that are slightly stained from my morning cup of coffee. Who am I kidding? CUPS of coffee. My daughter, by the way, looks gorgeous. I don’t see anything I’d change.
But would I be willing to touch up this photo? I know there isn’t much that can be done about my wind-blown hair. I have the software to smooth the bags and erase the smile lines around my eyes. I can clear up the blotches on my skin.
It won’t happen. I am keeping this photo as is because there is a story behind those bags, flat hair and make-up free face. As part of the trip, we slept (and I use the word “slept” very loosely because there wasn’t very much actual sleeping) on a bus, dressed for the day in a tiny bathroom in an over-crowded fast-food restaurant, walked through bitter cold and high winds miles to arrive where this photo was taken.
The photo reflects what happened that day, which is why I wouldn’t touch it up.
But not everyone feels this way. There was an article that I read recently that parents are paying to have their children’s school pictures touched up, and we aren’t talking about senior photos. This is being offered to elementary school students.
Really? We are expecting perfect photos of our kids?
In the article, one mom explains she opted to have her child’s photo touched up because the child had an outbreak of eczema.
So?
My daughter in that picture? We have a sports photo of her with a huge fat lip. Her sister, a teammate on her Little League team, had thrown a softball at her the day before pictures. In her individual photo, despite her fat lip, my daughter is smiling. The photo hints at a story, and it reminds of the event.
Years ago, in a crowded mall, my children sat on Santa Claus’ lap. One of them was screaming and crying, and her arms were stretched out to me, urging me to pick her up and take her away from this strange man. The photographer was trying to cajole her. I stopped the photographer, and I encouraged her to take the photo as is — screaming baby and all. It is a priceless memory that my kids still get a kick out of when it is put on display in our home every Christmas.
Imperfections aren’t something to hide or touch up. Sometimes the better story (and the better message to your children) is to show the flaws.















